Culture Wars(?): Remapping the Battleground
Argues that, contrary to advocates of the culture war thesis, there is not a great deal of polarization in US culture at the group & ideology levels. Proposed is a multidimensional model that understands the cultural battleground as one cross-cut along two dimensions: modernism/traditionalism & libertarianism/communalism. In a case study of the cultural conflict among US Mennonites, it is shown that this conceptualization better maps the existing cultural space in the US than static one-dimensional models, because it includes a role for fringe groups to influence the mainstream & opens space for inner-group conflict. While evidence exists for an increased polarization in US culture, it is concluded that efforts on both the Left & the Right to theorize this conflict have been overly simplistic & thus more politically expedient than helpful in imagining ways to reduce this tension. 2 Figures, 39 References. D. M. Ryfe